- Details
-
Opinion Pieces
-
Thursday, 14 June 2012 02:30
-
By caribarena staff reporter
During a session of Parliament, when the Motion of No-Confidence should have been debated, the ruling party released some additional documents relating to the Power Plant. While these are not nearly all the documents that the public deserves to see, it’s a start.
However, it seems that every single document contains more and more problems.
One such document is the Operation and Maintenance Agreement, signed by Mr. Clarvis Joseph, Chairman of the Board of Commissioners of the Antigua Public Utilities Authority (APUA); Ambassador David Shoul; representative for Beijing Construction (BCEG) Mr. Zhao Mai; and a Chinese Embassy official.
This document describes the operation and maintenance services that BCEG provides to APUA. It describes how BCEG handles all the maintenance services, trains APUA staff, and operates the power plant. However, under this Agreement, APUA is responsible to pay the following:
1. Travel Expenses: APUA must purchase one economy airplane ticket annually for every Chinese BCEG employee.
2. Prints and Reproductions: APUA pays for the cost of all prints and reproductions necessary for BCEG to perform contracted services.
3. Computer Services: APUA pays for any computer service charges incurred by BCEG in the performance of contracted services.
4. Materials and Equipment: APUA must pay for any and all equipment, consumables, materials, supplies, spare parts, tools, and miscellaneous supplies procured for the Power Plant. This means that whenever parts have to be replaced for any reason, APUA must foot the bill.
5. Transportation of Materials and Equipment: Not only does APUA pay for the equipment, parts, etc., but APUA must also pay for any and all shipping and transportation charges!
6. Utilities: Water, sewage, telephone, and waste disposal services for the Power Plant are all paid for by APUA.
7. Insurance Expenses: If anything needs to be insured by BCEG, APUA must pay up for the insurance expenses.
8. “Other: All other actual direct costs incurred in connection with the services” are paid by APUA.
So if APUA pays for all these things, you may ask how much is BCEG being paid, and for what?
Well, under this Agreement, BCEG is to be paid US$2 million over two years. And for what? For maintenance Services. APUA, and by extension, the Government, and by extension, the people, are paying BCEG over US$83,400 per month just for their time.
Additionally, the fact that all spare parts, materials and supplies must be paid for by APUA raises the question, what warranty does APUA have? Our limited information, thanks to the Government’s highly classified nature, indicates that there may not be any warranty at all.
But more importantly, Caribarena would like to know why documents are still being withheld from the public. This Operation & Maintenance Agreement specifically references the following reports:
1. Statement of Operation & Maintenance Costs Incurred by Year
2. Environmental, Health, and Safety Operating Plan
3. Budget
4. Annual Management Plan, which includes recommendations on the purchase of Equipment, Spare Parts, Consumables, tools, and other materials and supplies
5. Monthly Management Plan
6. Weekly Summary Reports of Production and Fuel Usage
At a time of such controversy, all of these reports would offer great insight into the Wadadli Power Plant. Releasing these reports would be a step in the right direction towards transparency.
So why does the Government refuse to release any documents? Why are these documents being kept under wraps? What do these, amongst other, documents contain that is so damning that the United Progressive Party (UPP) administration will keep them hidden even under great pressure from the public?
Bharrat Jagdeo, during his tenure as Prime Minister of Guyana, made an agreement with Chinese contractors for the US$150M expansion of the Cheddi Jagan International Airport (CJIA). This was kept mostly out of the public’s eye at the time.
On July 29, 2011, the World Bank announced the “debarment of China Communications Construction Company (CCCC) Limited, and all its subsidiaries, for fraudulent practices under Phase 1 of the Philippines National Roads Improvement and Management Project.”
http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/2011/07/29/world-bank-applies-2009-debarment-to-china-communications-construction-company-limited-for-fraud-in-philippines-roads-project.A manager at a CCCC subsidiary was later sentenced to death for accepting bribes. It was a subsidiary of the same company that received the contract for the Airport in Guyana. All of a sudden, former PM Jagdeo called on the current Prime Minister to review the contract. Jagdeo had previously taken a very defensive stance on the matter, but flipped following the World Bank’s announcement.
These two incidents are not so different. Both involve Chinese sub-contractors and contractors that had been involved in controversies. The contractor that worked in Guyana was debarred by the World Bank for corruption in the Philippines.
The World Bank also advised the East Timor Government not to work with a contractor who subcontracted XMEA for supplying power plant engines, a role they would later play in Antigua and Barbuda.
So what is our Government waiting for? Why is the Government fighting the people on this matter? Why should they need to fight, if they have nothing to hide?
See related stories:
Gaston Wants Respect On Power Plant Position
Government Tables Power Plant Documents
Petition to Release the Power Plant Documents
Picketers Write Ultimatum to Chinese
Things Fall Apart - Can the Gov’t Survive Waldadli
Bird Not Satisfied with GG's Response
Power Plant Price Comparison
Daniel’s Letter – The Fallout
ALP Transparent-See
Lone Wolf Group Accuses Spencer
Confident of No-Confidence
UPP’s Accountability and Transparency
Derrick Doubts Caribarena Photos
Lovell Roasted on Talk Show
Taking the Mickey Out of Spencer
Joseph Attacks Govt 'Dictatorship'
With Eyes Pressed Shut
More Support for MP Daniel
Bird Demands Answers About Power Plant Deal
No Voice Derrick - Serpent Charmed
MP Supports Daniel's Call
Daniel in the Lions Den
Daniel Demands Investigation into Chinese Power Plant
Shame and Outrage over Edwards' Commentary
Wrong Made Right
Money Talks - Power Plant Walks
Anti-Power Plant Pickets held in St John's
MP Joseph Exposes Critical APUA Reports
PM Blasts Molwyn Over Power Plant
Power Plant Companies Relationship Explained
Govt Promises Chinese Power Plant Answers
Another Unsettling Discovery at Power Plant
Bird To Seek Outside Advice on Power Plant
MP Joseph Accuses Government of Breaking Laws
Antigua Power Plant - No Straight Answers
Chinese Power Plant or Antigua's White Elephant
Power Plant Production Costs Explained
PM Says ALP Distorted Power Plant Info
No Plan Behind the Power Plant
39 Comments In This Article
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Dennis Brown
@ Shoul/Joseph/Sp encer
I call on the Christian Council to write the the GG and ask for her to instigate an inquiry! If they fail to do this, they should all be left alone on their pulpits each Sunday!
How can Soul even be able to face the Parishioners when he goes to church? He should write a letter calling for the inquiry to clear his family's name!
Then again he can only do that if his hands are "clean"!
Bishop Receipt
RE: Did They read before They Signed
• Is not true that all the existing problems created by the Stanford catastrophe are a direct result of bad decisions by the last ALP administration. ?
• Is it not true that it was the last ALP administration who sold to Stanford all the Airport Lands for less than EC$1.25 per sq. ft.?
• Is is not true that all the lands at the Airport were virtually given away to Stanford without any consideration given to future development of our Airport?
• Is it not true that the UPP administration have to pay in excess of $80.00 per sq. ft. for the same lands to build the new Airport terminal?
• Is it not true that your ten (10) year son has more common sense than to sell to Stanford or any other person those Airport lands that will be necessary for development now and again 50 and 100 years later?
• Was any” finder’s fee” or other commission paid to anyone???????
Eric
RE: Did They read before They Signed
SlyThatGuy
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Truth Be Told
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Concern Antiguan
WPP - Technology Transfer - The Wretchedness of Antigua & Barbuda Independence!
This "mere voice in the wilderness" has provided critical questions, analyses and some recommendations to my fellow Native Commenters, APUA Engineers, Technicians, Executives & Managers. As a PE, who has not inspected the Equipment & Plant, Legal & Ethics prohibit me from commenting on the authenticity & veracity as to their age. The documentation provided by this News Portal, APUA & Blue GoAB lead to other conclusions which have been commented upon. Remember my comment on the PRoC: They Shoot Horses! In the Fullness of Time!
Tenman & Dig It, evidence provided should not distract you from pursuit of Truth & Justice. Do not chase after a Fool's Long Lost Errand. In doing so, you fall into a similar trap as "the wannabe heir apparent and leadership hopefull", who by his ignorant pronouncements and following "Class Think" of some Doctoral Professionals with no Expertise in such matters when evidence has been exposed to his very eyes & in print and "living colour". Friends: 3 Words RWE. Respect!
John French II
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Made in China
where is our Judiciary
UPP Ponzi Scheme?
Is it a fact that they don't care since the responsible parties magistrate/judge?
Is it a fact that the judiciary can bring criminal charges without a costly inquiry to the taxpayers?
Is it a fact that the majority of Nationals don't give a damn?
Is it a fact that some of the money will be used to pay US law firms in the next
round of the R. Allen Stanford saga?
Jumbee Picknee
@ Godfather
Onlooker
Murder
benna
Rubbin alcohol
www.acronymfinder.com/Government-of-Antigua-and-Barbuda-%28GOAB%29.html
..
tenman
Rubbin alcohol
..
tenman
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Rubbin alcohol
A GOOD OLD PHRASE
Anu
People still asking questions
It is now time for action. The people must move now!!!
It Is Me
Dig It - Wild Wild west
..
tenman
@Godfather..did n't call your name!
Dig It
TRULY AMAZING
Anu
@Tenman
Dig It
FREEDOM TO THINK
Many people take the news at face value and accept everything reported as truth, though they are filled with lies to brainwash the gullible. My parents gave me the freedom to think, I am independent of anyones influence, so I can decide for myself, I know wrong from right, justice delayed to justice denied.
THE GODFATHER
THE GODFATHER
Quote:..
tenman
THREE BLIND MICE?
I see no reason for the report to be delayed, the DPPs slowness is tantamount to justice failure, and contrary to public accountability. The evidence is obvious.
THE GODFATHER
SUPPORT PUBLIC INTEREST
You are more "snake oil" and dangerous than anyone I know. Why not ask twist jaw how many insider deal he got from his business agents, and how many meetings benefited him.
Do you think buildings were built without under table rule, built for the government to own, is now their OWN!
Also, investment in the hospitality sector was not by accident, the students now pay the principal, the interest is theirs! So, too with POWER, the plant that you water with your ignorance is theirs, and that does not support our independence, support public interest and not private gain!
THE GODFATHER
Dig It - Release the (full) Bob Linquist report
..
tenman
GET REAL
Anna
Open freedom of information and lock up any guilty parties!
Dig It
Where are the documents?
Dig It
WHOSE INTEREST PUBLIC OR PRIVATE?
Also, why insert "But more importantly, Caribarena would like to know..." coincidentally serves your interest.
THE GODFATHER
Whar Happen to Clavis!
Can King David tell us who is selling all these parts to APUA ? !!! How many Chinese Companies like CCGC,BCEG,,XEMA ect are involved and who are the local middle -men????????????????????????
Come on dAVID,service to country should be your MANTRA'''',Not xxxxet!!!!
D. Merchant
TERM OF LOAN 30 YEARS
THE GODFATHER
REVIEW OUR RECORDS
Probably, IHI loan in 1984 for US$33 million at 8%',not much was repaid, Bruce Rapapport collected monthly payments of US$203,594 and deposited some in former MPs account.
Another APUA FUNDING US$13.7 million, daily interest US$2,573.41, an it's alleged as much as $92 million was diverted (ANTIGUA OBSERVER April 23, 2010)
And the cycle goes on an on, the Public Market scam etc......
THE GODFATHER
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Meanwhile, while these negotiations were taking place, a xxx agreement was reached between Baldwin Spencer, Antigua & Barbuda's Prime Minister and the Chinese Government to provide Antigua (and APUA) with its own new power plant to diminish, if not remove entirely, its dependence on the Hadeed-controll ed APC.
Active in this agreement was Antigua's Ambassador to China, the Honourable David Shoul, head of the other "power family" in Antigua.
What has emerged, in spite of the obfuscation and great stonewalling by the Prime Minister and a tightly knit group within his Cabinet, is a story of lies, evasions, xxxd and maladministration.
Following the money has led to the discovery of corporate entities, formed in China, after the loan agreement had been reached, acting as unspecified participants in a deal already made. It also identified vast overruns of costs finding their way to these entities. However, the final straw was the discovery that the equipment installed was not new, as originally agreed.
Reality
Reading is fundamental
PLM
cheap labor?
...
tenman
RE: Did They read before They Signed
R. Berry
NO ONE WILL EVER THINK FOR ME!
The document usually outline the necessary requirements from accommodation to maintenance, generallynthis is no different from global business practice.
There is no doubt corruption exist in business, not only in China but right here in fair Antigua & Barbuda, why cite a Chinese example and the monied few are protected in Anitigua. This article clearly demonstrates the particular business quarter funding this assault. Nomone will ever think for me!
THE GODFATHER
Fishy!!
young analyst
RE: Did They read before They Signed
Morris
RSS