Antigua and Barbuda

Partly Cloudy
81°F
High: 83°F
Low: 78°F
 

Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

Everette ChristianAntigua St John's - The government intends to tax allowances and benefits to plug a number of loopholes through which many people have successfully avoided paying their fair share of taxes.

That was the view of the government’s Revenue Reform Project Manager Everette Christian, speaking on a radio talk show on Sunday.

He explained that the Inland Revenue Department is merely enforcing legislation already on the books, and the move does not represent the introduction of new taxes.

He explained that when the law took effect in 2005, it made provision for taxing allowances and benefits. But he said representation was made to then finance minister, Dr Errol Cort, asking for additional time for adjustment to the new law.

According to Christian, Dr Cort decided to delay implementation until January 2006, but when that date came, for reasons unknown, the law was never implemented.

“We have seen cases where there have been declines in the amount of salaries paid to individuals, while at the same time we have witnessed a mushrooming of the amounts these individuals receive in allowances and benefits," he said.

"For example, we have seen examples where housing allowances may mushroom to $20,000 per month, while travelling allowances jump to between $4,000 and $5,000, and similar amounts for entertainment allowances."

The revenue reform project manager said it would have been a serious case of "dereliction of duty" if nothing was done to plug the loopholes.


He acknowledged that implementing the law at this time may represent a case of "Peter paying for Paul," but to minimize this, the department has embarked on a series of consultations to gather feedback from various interest groups before the measures take effect.

He disclosed that discussions have been held with groups including the Employers Federation, the Chamber of Commerce, and the Antigua Hotels and Tourist Association. At least one recommendation so far will be incorporated into the new policy.

Discussions with the Trade Union Congress (TUC) have not been as successful, Christian said. However, the department is committed to holding further discussions to arrive at a position that both sides will find acceptable.

Christian said the new proposals are not set in stone, and both he and the department are open to suggestions from anyone with ideas on how the law may be applied with as little pain as possible.


Meanwhile, head of the Private Sector Organisation (PSO), Patrick Ryan, said meetings have been held with the IRD, but no formal proposals have been submitted.

He acknowledged that some people have been abusing the law, but despite that, he feels that the proposals coming from the government are "too harsh," and the PSO will make a formal statement on the matter later this week.

See related stories:

Union Awaiting Response on Proposed Tax Changes

Hits: 2068

27 Comments In This Article   

HEADER   

please

#27 HC » 2012-01-10 13:06

Which loophole? The one that BS big gut bus out?
0
0
+
−

HC

fnspr

#26 ANTIGUAN WOMAN » 2012-01-10 12:36

Were,nt we paying all those taxes you mentioned before PIt was introduced?? The sales tax was introduced in order to remove some other taxes at the port,that i can tell you never happened,the sales tax is a complete new and additional one. Passport fees,birth /marriages/ death certificates fees were raised,Airport taxes were also increased. Your statement would leave one to believe that we had a free ride under the old model ,we paid taxes and paid heavily to under the ALP,the thing is what are we now receiving in terms of social services now that we,re paying PIT in addition to all the other new and increased taxes,than the yrs we paid no PIT???.Remember before 2004 we were told we were been over taxed, so how come all of a sudden PIT became a necessary part of our tax system,when we were told we were already paying too much? Someone please help me understand this kind of thinking.
1
0
+
−

ANTIGUAN WOMAN

fnpsr

#25 tenman » 2012-01-10 10:35

fnpsr the majority of our taxes have always come via indirect taxes. This is the same way it works in places like the Bahamas. Again these places were what the labor party government used as a model when they removed income tax in 1976. I will continue to say like the chairman of APUA, Clavis Joseph, said before 2004, that Antigua does not have a revenue problem but instead has a expenditure problem. Pay attention to what the added moneys garnered from the income tax were used for: They were wasted on things like imporperly constructed fences and buildings and gutters in Saint John's that had to be dug up. The government also spent some 900 million on roads which are nowhere worth even thirty percent of that amount. These added moneys have simply been an added excuse to waste more. In the mean time individuals have simply become poorer. fnspr don't you think that the people who worked hard for their moneys know best how to spend it? fnspr no matter the tax system, it must provide value to residents and citizens. The implemenation of the income tax in Antigua is a good example of value destruction.
..
..
0
0
+
−

tenman

re: tenman - part 2 & final

#24 fnpsr » 2012-01-09 23:12

Now, imagine that the income tax for 2012 is abandoned. This would mean that a big chunk of the lost revenue would have to be made up. It would have to come from increased fees such as, ABST, port fees, property taxes, embarkation tax, passport fees, land transfer fees, car registration fees, drivers’ license fees, SS, MBS, Ed. Levy and the like. Furthermore, every time there is a short fall, the fees would go up with a stroke of the pen.

Remember, there is no free lunch!

As I said before, the entire tax system needs to be revamped.

“Let’s fix the little things before we attempt to fix the big things.”
0
1
+
−

fnpsr

re: tenman - part 1

#23 fnpsr » 2012-01-09 23:11

Tenman, thanks for responding. I do not know how those countries that you have mentioned have been able to not have any income tax. I will leave that research to you. But I would think that they have alternate sources of income, probably through fees, VAT, sales tax and the like.

I think we have to have a hard look at ourselves and ask, can we be like those other countries? I am sure they are well established with rules that don’t change from day to day to fit the political wind. I am also sure that those countries are also well managed compared to Antigua.

For Antigua, I still believe that some form of income tax is necessary. As I said before, the question is what is fair and just?
1
0
+
−

fnpsr

fnpsr

#22 tenman » 2012-01-09 22:16

fnpsr after reading the first paragraph in the first part of your post, I wondered aloud how places like the Bahmas, Burmuda, Swizerland survive without income tax? Wern't these the models that the Antiguan economy was based on?

..
0
0
+
−

tenman

some form of income tax is necessary - part 3 & final

#21 fnpsr » 2012-01-09 20:50

Allowances, such as the hotel service charge is income and therefore should be included in the workers gross income and be subject to the tax code.

The way to avoid the confusion is to include all earned and non-earned income, from all sources, to arrive at the total income. Then you subtract certain enumerated deductions and then apply the appropriate percentage to the net income and forward the result to the IRD.

“Let’s fix the little things before we attempt to fix the big things.”
0
0
+
−

fnpsr

some form of income tax is necessary - part 2

#20 fnpsr » 2012-01-09 20:50

There is something inherently wrong in a small island like Antigua, when one would be receiving a housing allowance of $20, 000 per month. This is clearly an attempt to circumvent the tax code. One should be reminded that you are talking about the taxpayers’ money and therefore the prudent man rule should always apply. Spend it as if you were spending your own money, or as a reasonable person would do under the same or similar circumstances.

A housing allowance would be authorized where it is beneficial to the government for carrying out it services. Because of the size of the island, I can think of no position that would merit a housing allowance. Anyone and everyone are within a stone’s throw of any emergency that would arise on the island and could be there within minutes.
0
0
+
−

fnpsr

some form of income tax is necessary - part 1

#19 fnpsr » 2012-01-09 20:47

I will start by saying that some form of income tax is necessary. Without it, the government, red or blue, will not be able to provide the required services to the people of the island. In turn, the government will have to look to other outside sources to find money to provide the needed services. The question is, what level of taxation is just and fair? I will leave this up to you.

The problem I see with the tax system, is that there is no coherent tax system. The politicians that write the tax code, write it out of pure political expediency. Therefore, as I have stated before., the tax entire tax system needs to be revamped.

To address the issue at hand, allowances such as the one Dadliman described should not be taxed unless it can be shown to be exorbitant, unreasonable and clearly to avoid the tax code. Where it is shown to be exorbitant, the amount that is above the threshold would be included in income and be subject to the tax code.
1
1
+
−

fnpsr

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#18 Ciego Montero » 2012-01-09 19:30

When the government stated last year that only six doctors and about 5 lawyers were paying income tax, how do you suppose this was possible? Light bulb!! They declare their salaries to be $2900/month and take the rest as allowance. It even happens in government statutory bodies. Just imagine!! So the $20,000 in allowances for a business owner and highly paid exec is not a stretch. This was always coming...and it now has to be across the board perhaps with an exemption cap. If it is not implemented across the board, the affected will have a case for discrimination. Now the question is why was this evasion/avoidan ce allowed to go on for so long?
0
1
+
−

Ciego Montero

Dadliman its too late to stop the countdown

#17 OUTOFANTIGUA » 2012-01-09 16:58

tick tick tick the self destruct **on has already been activated.These wounded animals are dangerous and its not wise to get in their way as they try to escape.
0
0
+
−

OUTOFANTIGUA

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#16 kim john dead » 2012-01-09 16:26

he is a good man so back off people ,he was working with the alp too ,,,,,,,,,,,blam e the upp not this one individual
1
3
+
−

kim john dead

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#15 piky head » 2012-01-09 15:43

no problem. just set the example.
1
0
+
−

piky head

@ Mr. Chrisitian

#14 Wow » 2012-01-09 15:36

There is a simple reason why salaries are decreasing Mr. Chrisitian. We have had to take paycuts and less profits to keep our employees employed since you and the UPP has screwed our economy you jackazz.
3
2
+
−

Wow

Stimulus Time!

#13 JP Farnsworth » 2012-01-09 15:00

Looks Like I have to fix this mess too. Mr. Christian you can not raise taxes now. We need a stimulus. Tax Cuts will help the economy more than taxing us harder. Even the US congress got their act together long enough to hold off on tax increases. Bad timing dude. If we have money to spend then you will collect more taxes when business grows. Tax us and business will die and you get no taxes at all. Are we good now? Now I will send you my bill for explaining this.
7
0
+
−

JP Farnsworth

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#12 DadliMan » 2012-01-09 14:37

Hate to keep beating a seemingly dead horse, but what exactly is the ALP doing? Beside releasing press statements and chatting on ZDK, the ALP has been the best kept secret in A&B. And they tell me they want to run this country again? Clearly, they have resolved to sit quietly and hope that the UPP self-destructs.

I wish the ALP would study the tenure of the UPP in opposition. That is how an opposition party conducts business. Had all of this been happening under an ALP administration, the UPP would turned this country upside-down. The ALP, on the other hand, has decided that playing dead is the best form of offence they can muster.
6
0
+
−

DadliMan

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#11 DadliMan » 2012-01-09 13:56

These people really haven't got a clue. They have squandered our hard-earned tax dollars, and now that their dismal performance has prohibited them from getting any more IMF funds, they are looking to dig their hands deeper into our pockets.

If they are aware of specific abuses of the tax system, then deal with the abusers. When I use my vehicle in the course of doing my job, and I get a $450 monthly transportation allowance, I am now supposed to pay taxes on that? The $450 is a paltry sum when one considers the state of the roads and the price of gas. Are politicians going to pay taxes on all the perks (e.g. their utility bills)?

The unions need to start mobilising the membership from now. The administration has a history of ignoring the wishes of the people, so it is hardly likely that they will change their minds. It is time to start talking about a GENERAL STRIKE. Maybe this will be the beginning of the end of this disaster!! ong>
3
0
+
−

DadliMan

@ G. tree

#10 Dessalines » 2012-01-09 10:19

The cap is an excellent idea. Maybe you should call a meeting with the finance ministry and plug your ideas.
3
2
+
−

Dessalines

temporary?

#9 tenman » 2012-01-09 09:51

When Dr.Cort stated the the rules for Income tax when it comes to allowances would be the same as it was for SS, it was an effort to simplify things. He recognised the choas it would cause trying to enforce things like taxing meals and travel. It unfair for the minister of finance to suggest, as done during the 2012 budget debate, that Hotel workers would receive service charge tax free, yet outside of the hotel environment bonuses will be taxed. Following the income tax law even a chistmas or birthday gift would be taxed. I will continue to argue that income tax makes no sense due to the high costs to enforce it and its negative affect on gaining the investers on we claim we desire.
..
3
0
+
−

tenman

On Dr. Cort

#8 JP Farnsworth » 2012-01-09 09:27

He delayed it to 2006 because he is probably the biggest offender. He should be the first one to start filling out travel expense reports.
5
0
+
−

JP Farnsworth

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#7 More tax equal less » 2012-01-09 09:27

Re-introduce income tax after decades = less revenue for Govt
Introduce ABST for 1st time = less revenue for Govt
Introduce more taxes on allowances = guess what?

Google "Laffer curve"
But we all know how this is going to go. Short-term cash grab so that we can have money for "political projects" for points to the long term detriment of the economy as we have reduced spending and contraction on the economy. The evidence is clear....just look around and there have been global recessions before so we cannot keep blaming that when there is no stimulus in the economy.
5
1
+
−

More tax equal less

THIS YA NEED DIVINE INTERVENTION

#6 ANTIGUAN WOMAN » 2012-01-09 09:26

Businesses are closing daily,the Economy has seen negative growth for the past 3yrs or more,unemployme nt is rising as business close their doors and no new avenue is created to absorb them.Cost of living is rising steadily,electr icity bills are sky high,with all this in mind the Govt has found this a fitting time to tax a little more,the loophole they have to fill will never be filled,because its not a hole,its a bottomless pit,they must be paying the devil. Antiguans need to get rid of this Govt,they are killing us slowly,a new yr has just started and the depression continues.
7
2
+
−

ANTIGUAN WOMAN

Expense Reports please

#5 JP Farnsworth » 2012-01-09 09:26

Okay I'm going to close the budget gap here we go.
1. A travel expense are to be put on a report. All left over monies are to be returned to the treasury. (I bet that hurts)
2. No more first class tickets (that means if your over weight you gonna have to diet to fit your big ** in the seat)
3. No more last minute plane tickets for full fare. Everyone travels Economy booked in advance like the rest of us.
4. Central purchasing all supplies pens, pencils, and so bought in bulk and dispensed.
5. Trip logs for all vehicles. Or tracking devices.
6. Tracking devices on all police cars no more personal trips or speeding.
7. Stop buying things on credit, you have no money don't buy it.
Pay my bill now
9
0
+
−

JP Farnsworth

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#4 Morris » 2012-01-09 06:30

"For example, we have seen examples where housing allowances may mushroom to $20,000 per month, while travelling allowances jump to between $4,000 and $5,000, and similar amounts for entertainment allowances."

With those figures he must be talking about politicians, because I know that there are many citizens who don't see those figures on their pay stubs. No wonder the implementation was delayed without explanation.
5
0
+
−

Morris

RE: Govt Wants Tax to Plug Loopholes

#3 WAWA » 2012-01-09 06:05

"According to Christian, Dr Cort decided to delay implementation until January 2006, but when that date came, for reasons unknown, the law was never implemented". COULD IT BE, YOU FOOL, THAT IT WAS RECOGNISED THAT IT WOULD BRING FURTHER HARDSHIP ON PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTRY? MR. CHRISTIAN, IF ONE OF YOUR FINGER IS BAD DO YOU CUT OFF ALL OF YOUR FINGERS? IN MY OPINION IT IS BECAUSE OF PEOPLE LIKE YOU WHY THIS COUNTRY IS IN THE POSITION IT IS. TO MY RECOLLECTION, YOU ARE ON OF THE "PRIVATE SECTOR WORKERS" WHO LEFT THE PRIVATE SECTOR TO COME INTO THE PUBLIC SECTOR AND SUDDENLY REALIZE, HEY THE PUBLIC SECTOR NEEDS TO BE TRIMMED BUT YOU NAR GO NO WHERE!! YOU ARE NOT TO BE "TRIMMED"!!. PEOPLE LIKE YOU MAKE ME SICK. MR. CHRISTIAN, I WILL SHARE SOME TEACHINGS FROM MY BIBLE WITH YOU. THERE IS A PART THAT SAYS "TO THE 3RD AND 4TH GENERATION MR. CHRISTIAN".
2
1
+
−

WAWA

cap

#2 G.tree » 2012-01-09 04:44

Why don't you cap the allowances at say $800.00, anything over that will be taxable. Or even a percentage of the persons salary.

This would be a lot more considerate than just being greedy and taxing all of the allowances.
6
0
+
−

G.tree

Government wants to plug loopholes

#1 Taxed Out » 2012-01-09 03:48

My business done taxed out ...what loopohle? I cant even take a salary for the past 2 years much more pay myself any allowaance...I am barely surviving...tel l the Government bring some real level of investment to boost thsi econonmy and find away to work with the business owners on a more "fair" level of taxation so business people can plug the "sinking business hole" in this sunken economy!!!
6
0
+
−

Taxed Out

Add comment

World News

Follow us on Facebook

Spotlight on Business

Previous Next
Social Media Exposes Illegal Workers
Antigua St. John's - The saga of illegal workers at Il Giardino, the fine dining...  Read more

Latest Economy News

Search Directory


Directory Listings


Little B & J

  LITTLE B and J Auto parts and Accessories Located on the Herberts Main Road is your one stop source for all you auto parts needs.Our kind and ...



The Stock Exchange

For buying & selling top quality used items. "You never know what you need until you see it".

Category: Shopping

App

Android LogoDownload Caribarena's Android App Click To Download

Find us on Twitter!