Antigua and Barbuda

Mostly Cloudy
79°F
High: 83°F
Low: 78°F
 

Separation Of Ministries of Finance and Economy Moted

Dr McChesney EmanuelAntigua St John's - The Ministry of Finance should be separated from Economic Development to allow these entities to perform their respective roles more efficiently.

The suggestion comes from Antigua & Barbuda's consul general in New York, Dr McChesney Emanuel, in part two of his exclusive interview with Caribarena.com.

While acknowledging that the final decision is up to local policymakers, Dr Emanuel said he nonetheless would like to place the suggestion on the table for consideration as the country seeks to achieve economic growth and social development.

“We need to look at how we structure our ministries," he said. "Not all our ministries are structured to entertain and maximize opportunities that come our way. For example, I would have preferred to see a Ministry of Economic Development separate from the Ministry of Finance. We should be establishing a ministry that is exclusively for economic development. If structured right, this could go a long way in helping the country achieve its goals."

The diplomat said his comments were general, and not specifically geared at Minister of Finance and the Economy Harold Lovell, who is doing a good job despite the challenges. “I give Minister Lovell good marks for stepping up to the plate in this way… by taking bold steps to restructure the department,” Dr Emanuel said.


He likened the Ministry of Finance to the Federal Reserves in the United States that regulates monetary and fiscal policies, while economic development is handled by the Department of Commerce.

Dr Emanuel, who has spent over 30 years living and working in the United States as a businessman, educator, and now a diplomat, said it is imperative for countries like Antigua & Barbuda to quickly adapt to the requirements of a global economy.

“Evolving entities have to shed old characteristics, as these times call for dynamic structures; decisions must be made in real time. Waiting an inordinate length of time to make a decision could cost the country a project,” he said.


Dr Emanuel, who was the head of a public school in the New York area, made a case not only for reform of the nation’s institutions, but also for ongoing training and evaluation.

“We have to focus on a vision and cultivate a culture of management by constantly training our people," he said. "Notwithstanding this, there must be constant evaluation, as this is the only way to keep oneself at the frontline."

See related stories:

Local Institutions Unprepared for Investment

Hits: 1966

16 Comments In This Article   

HEADER   

...OUR NATION...

#16 Jumbee Picknee » 2011-12-07 18:47

Again folks, OUR NATION is ANTIGUA, BARBUDA and REDONDA. Please, please, please stop leaving out Redonda. Redonda is very important in many ways...
1...it give us our Nautical boundary to enhance and support our fishing industry.
2...it can be used to transfer the troubled quarry from Bendals to.
3...it can also be used to relocate the national sanitaton dump to
4...excellent location for a recycling plant.
5...it is an excellent location for the relocation of the prison.
Barges can be used to transport workers, trash etc.
0
0
+
−

Jumbee Picknee

...Political Action Committee...

#15 Jumbee Picknee » 2011-12-07 18:40

Greetings...
I have read a lot of the comments and reasoning aon this site, and I must say that, we have a great thing going here. What I would like to see however, is the formation of an official Political Action Committee or PAC as it is called in many political circles. This would NOT be beholden to any party or group, but mainly to reason and put our collective, cognitive minds together for the positive future of our Nation. None of us are perfect, yet we all have perfect piece's to paint a better picture of our Nation. Just like any puzzle, one piece depends on another to depict the entire concept. For those interested, my email address is .
Once upon a time, I almost lost my mind, but I found truth...can u feel me. And, each and every day, as love did come my way, it felt so good, can you hear me. So, to you I have to say, in a very special way, I love you, Antigua, Barbuda and Redonda.
0
0
+
−

Jumbee Picknee

RE: Separation Of Ministries of Finance and Economy Moted

#14 Pellucid » 2011-12-07 10:35

That "some reason" you're referring to is called: Due Diligence.
0
0
+
−

Pellucid

@Avid Reader & Tenman

#13 Skyewill » 2011-12-06 21:21

I agree with some of your points and I know That investors have been introduced to Antigua. For some reason they keep walking after they talk to our people. Avid reader. I believe Economic developement can be seperate because i have seen this work in many places. There is a difference between economic developement and the economy although they are closely related. The need to find, manage and support investment need to be seperate. we can afford it by iliminating the fluff
0
0
+
−

Skyewill

@skyewell

#12 Avid Reader » 2011-12-06 18:08

When I look at Antigua & Barbuda, I see a country with a population of about 85,000 people. A new ministry would run us about let's say 7mil, why spend that money when it is easier to do it in the office of finance, since that is where it belongs. They hired Mac and his crew to also look to bring businesses to Antigua, in my book that is part of economic development.

Mac Emmanuel cannot now be critizing the process after 7 years. What has he been doing all this time?, There are a lot of Antiguans and Barbudans in NY who know a hell of a lot, but they would never go to them. He is patting the minister on the back but at the same time saying they don't know what they are doing.

The question is for whose benefit is he now critizing?
0
1
+
−

Avid Reader

Skyewill - its short term thinking

#11 tenman » 2011-12-06 16:50

Skyewill, I suspect the answer more lies in that we dislike plans. They are too structured and keep us from doing what we like. This might even be adjudged to a lack of discipline. If you examine how MP Lovell came up with the 1500 cap on electricity you will see lack of discipline in that exercise. Even if we did what Emanuel touts, the ministry would not contribute anything positive. When was the last time since independence that we had a balanced budget? If we can't even adhere to a budget why would you think we would adhere to a economic plan? Though we like the idea of touting plans, its only as an academic exercise or a stalling tactic. I happen to think there is no need for separate entities. The national economic council was a good idea but instead of funding it, we found other uses, based on short term motives, for the moneys. I think its all comes down to the fact that we are driven by the short term, and until that changes, making long term plans will result in a wasted exercise.

..
1
0
+
−

tenman

Great Idea Mac

#10 Skyewill » 2011-12-06 16:05

I keep saying we should bring this guy home to help solve some of these issues. poor mac, it must be hard banging you head on the wall, i stopped. it is not just looking for investment. You must have an investment plan/Strategy. I can't keep saying things and five years later you guys get it. We have to know what we want investors to invest in, therefore each investment idea needs a business plan. Truthfully i don't believe any in finance know how to write a plan cause i saw one on the government website on Energy and it reads like a gindergarden book. we will need to spend money just for the plan and creativity is the key. If we change the political structure and move from a slave commonwealth to a republic Mr. Emanuel would make a very good President. I would vote for him.
0
3
+
−

Skyewill

Right again

#9 St. Philips North » 2011-12-06 12:22

Mack is right, when V.C. toke office in 1976 he created a Minisrty of Econ, Lester head that ministry and it was the ministry that grow Antigua and Barbuda, all the ministry did was to find investments,
3
1
+
−

St. Philips North

What is this man talking about?

#8 Avid Reader » 2011-12-06 10:43

Why should there be another ministry created? for a small country and not to waste the citizens money, if he wants it created it should be under the department of finance.

Some of the facets of economic development are part of Emanuel's job, unless he didn't understand what his job was.

As much as he tried to not insult Lovell, his comments are insulting and roughly telling the Minister he doesn't know how to do his job.
2
2
+
−

Avid Reader

@ UK ANU PART II

#7 THINKING BIG » 2011-12-06 10:24

Working together is not the same as eliminating distinct functions. I agree with Dr. Emmanuel that it would be more efficient and effective for finance and economy to be seperated so that optimal results ensues.

The only reason the UPP brought these two together was because that fool from Trinidad Roy Bokye felt it would be a sign of Change to rename ministries. But that idiot knows nothing of how good goverance operates. You understand why Daniel had to kick him out of Antigua?

Stop writing nonesense and pretensing that you making sense.

Go back and do some serious reading and reflection. Your comment embr** both the UK and Anu!
3
2
+
−

THINKING BIG

@ UK ANU PART I

#6 THINKING BIG » 2011-12-06 10:21

Clearly you have lost your sound thinking way. Why not in a small island like Anu integrate the GG's office witht he PM's office? What does size have to do with efficiency of organizational functions?

I agree that the US and the UK governmental systems are different but I don't see why one can't draw out the best models of opertional excellence from either/or system to ascertain what's best for national growth.

The ministery of finance main function is fiscal discipline. The ministry of economic main function is the creation of growth. The first seeks to cut back on spending, the latter desires to spend/invest.

Both the stomach and the womb is needed for the making of a healthy baby but no woman wants to integrate her stomach into her womb just to have a good pregnancy. Analogy not perfect but make**.
..
4
3
+
−

THINKING BIG

@Skyewill

#5 Morris » 2011-12-06 10:19

I can teach them how to do that when I establish my OD firm.
0
2
+
−

Morris

RE: Separation Of Ministries of Finance and Economy Moted

#4 UK/ANU Student » 2011-12-06 08:07

cont'd

.....The idea of imposing a similar role like the US Fed. Reserve on the Ministry of Finance is RUBBISH!!! The US Federal Reserve is the US' Central Bank!!!! The Eastern Caribbean Central Bank is responsible for REGULATING monetary and fiscal policies. It's the job for the Ministry of Finance & Economy (the ministry we invented and has been working for years) to create and manage policies in line with that of the Central Bank. Finance and Economics are siblings, you cannot separate the two in a small economy like ours. When individual speak, they need to be informed and STOP MISLEADING PEOPLE!. Another thing, In Antigua, we like to compare the US System of Gov't to that of our...which is simply apples and oranges...TWO TOTALLY DIFFERENT SYSTEMS. That's like in Law comparing the Civil Law System with the Common Law System.

Therefore my advice to individuals like Dr. Emmanuel (who has been living away for ages) is to simply do your research, do not speak to areas where you are incompetent to speak to and stop comparing us to America!
6
1
+
−

UK/ANU Student

RE: Separation Of Ministries of Finance and Economy Moted

#3 UK/ANU Student » 2011-12-06 08:07

Firstly, correction to the title: It is "Mooted" and not "Moted".

Secondly, I am still waiting to read a valid and logical reason why the two should be separated. Finance and Economic Development goes hand in hand. If we look at the UK (where our model is mirrored & NOT THE US), the Exchequer in addition to revenue management and tax collection set the agenda when it comes to development. However, they have created a separate Ministry called "Business, Innovation and Skills" which is responsible for fostering economic developments, regulation, higher education and many more. See http://www.bis.gov.uk/. This ministry however works closely with the Exchequer-(more a historic ministry)......
5
0
+
−

UK/ANU Student

Continuing Education

#2 Skyewill » 2011-12-06 06:22

Without ongoing training and evaluation the nation will die. This is the number one reason we are in such a mess. Take a guy with a Masters Degree earned in 2000, That was more than 10 years ago. The entire knowledge base have expanded yet with no continuing education he is stuck in 2000. Everyone need training even the PM and the Governor General, EVERYONE. From the bottom to the top no exceptions and the ministry of education need to look at training government workers all the time. There must be a department responsibel for training and developement outside of the public school system.
8
0
+
−

Skyewill

RE: Separation Of Ministries of Finance and Economy Moted

#1 Pellucid » 2011-12-06 03:01

In order to regulate monetary policy, you must control the currency. Is this gentleman ignorant of the fact that Antigua does not have its own currency, or (more likely) he has no idea what monetary policy is?
12
1
+
−

Pellucid

Add comment

World News

Follow us on Facebook

Spotlight on Business

Previous Next
Social Media Exposes Illegal Workers
Antigua St. John's - The saga of illegal workers at Il Giardino, the fine dining...  Read more

Latest Economy News

Search Directory


Directory Listings


Mentor After School Centre

For Primary and Secondary Students   Parents and Guardians Do you struggle with your child’s homework after working all day?Is your child ...

Category: After School


Living Spaces

  Living Spaces   Is a family owned business that has been established in Antigua for over 35 years. They offer contemporary to traditional styles ...


App

Android LogoDownload Caribarena's Android App Click To Download

Find us on Twitter!